Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Money · Advice & Questions ·

Should we recalculate last year's shared subscription because one housemate barely used it?

Money category photographMoney

Three of us agreed to split a permitted household subscription equally for a year. Using illustrative figures, it cost $180, so we paid $60 each. One housemate used it twice; the other two used it regularly.

As renewal approaches, he wants $50 of his contribution returned and says the heavy users should cover the difference. We all had access for the full year, and we never agreed to divide the price by usage. But I can see why two evenings now feel expensive to him.

I'm happy to choose a different arrangement next year. I'm less sure about reopening a price the other two of us thought was settled. How would you separate a fair renewal discussion from a retrospective bill?

Discussion

5 community replies

The equal split bought each person access, which is what you agreed at the time. I'd start there without dismissing his disappointment. A poor-value year for him doesn't automatically tell the other two what extra amount they agreed to pay.

At renewal, ask whether he actually wants to participate. Keeping the same three-way arrangement to avoid an awkward conversation could leave everyone repeating this dispute a year later.

If the two heavy users actively pushed for this subscription while he was unsure, that history might matter to a goodwill compromise. It's worth hearing how the original decision happened before reducing the whole discussion to login counts.

Sixty dollars for two uses would feel like a bad deal. The others enjoyed most of the benefit, so a partial refund doesn't seem like an unreasonable thing to ask for.

He can reasonably ask, and you can consider it. The difficulty is making that request into a new bill for the others after the year is over. Any goodwill refund should be something you now agree to, while the next year's participation is decided openly before payment.

Join the discussion

More in Money