Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Parenting · Advice & Questions ·

Should we query a school prize if my daughter's recorded score looks too high?

Parenting category photographParenting

My nine-year-old has been told she'll receive a prize for the highest score in a school quiz. She's thrilled. Her marked paper says 19 out of 25, but the results sheet brought home with it lists her as 24. Another child is listed on 22.

I can't tell whether there was an adjustment we weren't told about or a copying mistake. My daughter says the teacher gave her the result, so it must be right. My partner thinks emailing now would make her feel accused of cheating when she hasn't done anything dishonest.

I don't want to take her certificate away in advance of knowing the answer. I also don't want to tell her that a possible mistake is best left alone when it benefits us. The presentation is next week; nothing has been awarded yet.

How much should I involve her in asking school to check the two scores? Is there a way to keep this a quiet factual query rather than making her publicly confess to something she didn't do?

Discussion

5 community replies

Send the discrepancy, not a verdict: "Her paper shows 19 and the results sheet shows 24. Could you check which total is correct before the presentation?" Include both documents. That gives school something precise to resolve without alleging that anyone cheated.

Tell her before you email. Finding out later that you queried her prize in secret could feel like a separate betrayal. You can say you don't yet know which number is right and that you would ask about a lower recorded score, too.

Her correct answers remain hers whichever total is confirmed. I would praise those specific parts now rather than promise the prize will stay. If the total changes, let her be disappointed without adding a speech about how a good person would feel pleased to give it up.

I agree with your partner about avoiding an accusation, but asking the organiser to check paperwork isn't accusing your daughter. There is no need to make her stand up in class or write an apology for an adult recording error.

And if school confirms an error, the organiser can explain the corrected result. She may choose to say something kind to the eventual winner, but that shouldn't become a public performance she must give to prove she deserved to be trusted in the first place.

Join the discussion

More in Parenting