Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Housing · Advice & Questions ·

Should we pay mortgage points if we do not know how long we will keep the loan?

Housing category photographHousing

The lender showed us a lower-rate option with discount points. My partner prefers it because the monthly payment is smaller. I am looking at how much more cash we would use at closing.

For an illustration, suppose the extra upfront cost is $3,000 and the comparable monthly principal-and-interest saving is $50. Dividing those amounts gives 60 months, but that rough calculation does not establish the best choice for our actual US purchase. We have not confirmed that the quotes differ only in those items.

The CFPB recommends comparing options with and without points, including cash needed at closing and costs over the period you expect to keep the loan.

What would you check before using a break-even figure? We might stay for years, but work could also take us elsewhere, and I do not want either possibility treated as certain.

Discussion

5 community replies

Ask for comparable Loan Estimates with the same loan amount, type and term, and have every cost difference explained. Check whether either quote includes lender credits or other changed fees. A monthly saving has to be measured against the actual additional cost you would pay.

Consider the cash left after closing as well as the monthly payment. If the upfront payment would use money you need for the move or a reserve, make that trade-off explicit. A favourable long-term comparison does not make the immediate cash requirement disappear.

Could you compare a shorter and longer period of keeping the loan, without declaring either your forecast? That would show which uncertainty is driving the choice.

Use plausible periods and the actual quotes, then discuss what result you can tolerate if life changes. Include a sale or a replacement loan as a scenario to assess, rather than an event you promise will happen on a particular date.

Join the discussion

More in Housing