Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Parenting · Advice & Questions ·

Should turning six mean my child stops sleeping with his comfort toy?

Parenting category photographParenting

My son is about to turn six. While talking about his birthday, I said that being a big schoolchild would mean leaving his bear on the shelf at night. He asked why growing up meant he could not have something that helps him feel comfortable.

The bear stays in his bed. It is not preventing him from going to school or joining activities. I had pictured this birthday as the right time to move on, but I cannot identify a problem the change would solve for him.

The American Academy of Pediatrics describes comfort objects as a source of support in the early years and says they are not evidence of weakness or insecurity. That has made me question the meaning I attached to putting the bear away.

Should I withdraw the birthday deadline? I want to encourage him to try things for himself without making a familiar bedtime comfort the proof that he is old enough.

Discussion

5 community replies

Withdraw the deadline if you cannot explain what it is meant to fix. You can say, “I connected turning six with putting your bear away, but I don't need you to do that for your birthday.” Changing your mind can be a complete decision rather than a postponement until seven.

The AAP's discussion challenges the idea that a comfort object signals weakness. It does not give you a birthday test for this child. Keep the conversation grounded in the actual situation: the bear is in his bed, and you have not described it stopping ordinary activities.

Choose independence goals that have something to do with his daily life and that you can support, such as taking a part in getting his school things ready. There is no need to make every new responsibility conditional on surrendering a comfort first.

Ask whether he wants the bear to stay as part of bedtime, without presenting the question as an opportunity to give the approved grown-up answer. He may simply want the arrangement he already has.

Then accept that answer without reopening the vote each night. If a practical issue arises later, discuss that issue when it exists. His birthday can mark new choices and responsibilities while the bear remains on his pillow.

Join the discussion

More in Parenting