Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Parenting · Advice & Questions ·

Should the guest always choose what the children play?

Parenting category photographParenting

My ten-year-old invited a friend over to build a cardboard marble track. Once they arrived, the friend wanted to play a video game instead. I told my son that guests got to choose, so he should put the track away.

Later he said that at his friend's house the rule was that the host chose. "So he chooses at both houses." I haven't discussed that account with the other family, and I don't know whether it was a general rule or something said on one occasion.

I was trying to make our guest feel welcome. My son says inviting someone now means giving up the activity he was excited to share. His friend wasn't rude about the track; the two children had barely started talking about options before I settled it.

What should hosting require here? I want them to consider each other without creating a rule that one child always gets the final say, or treating friendship as a tally of whose game won last time.

Discussion

5 community replies

If those two rules are being applied that way, his arithmetic makes sense. You can acknowledge it without declaring the other family unfair. The rule you can reconsider immediately is the one you used in your own living room.

They hadn't finished discussing it before you chose a winner. Next time, give them room to suggest a plan together. You can help if they get stuck, but being welcoming needn't mean overruling the host child at the first different suggestion.

The visiting child should be able to decline an activity, too. Your son can invite someone to build, but that doesn't make the guest his pupil for the whole afternoon. The aim can be to find something they are both willing to do.

An invitation with a particular plan can help set expectations: "Would you like to come over and build this track?" That gives the friend useful information before arriving. It also lets your son say what he is actually excited about.

And if the friend accepts, they can still discover they'd like to do something else for part of the visit. A stated plan gives them a starting point; it doesn't have to become another rule that prevents either child from speaking when their preference changes.

Join the discussion

More in Parenting