Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Technology · Advice & Questions ·

Should our drawing challenge allow AI-generated entries if we haven't agreed what the challenge is for?

Technology category photographTechnology

Our hobby group announced a weekly “draw a doorway” prompt. A member asked whether an AI-generated image could count. We hadn't stated a process rule.

Some people want practice with drawing; others like seeing different ways of developing an idea. I can see a worthwhile challenge in either version, but judging them as though we had all agreed on the same activity feels unfair.

How would you clarify it before entries are due, without turning a reasonable question into an accusation of cheating? We can change future prompts, and this one needs an explanation people can understand.

Discussion

5 community replies

Start with the purpose: practising drawing, exploring an idea through any method, or sharing work without judging it. An entry rule follows more clearly from that choice than from deciding whether a particular member's proposed tool is respectable.

If several approaches are welcome, ask for a brief process description so people know what they are looking at. That could support conversation about the work without pretending everyone performed the same exercise.

Separate categories or an unjudged sharing week might be proportionate options. You don't have to construct a complicated competition system for a hobby prompt, but you do need to explain what any comparison is meant to recognise.

Acknowledge that the announcement was incomplete and clarify the arrangement before people finish work. Apply the explanation fairly instead of treating an unstated expectation as something the questioner deliberately broke.

Keep the explanation specific to this challenge and the information needed to take part. A brief description of the process needn't become a demand for every draft, private prompt or account history. Clarity should make participation easier, not create another contest over proving effort.

Join the discussion

More in Technology