Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Parenting · Advice & Questions ·

Should my child use an adult's first name when the adult has asked her to?

Parenting category photographParenting

Our family friend introduced herself to my nine-year-old as Jo and said, “Please call me Jo.” My daughter did. Later, Grandpa corrected her to “Mrs Clarke” and said children should show respect to adults.

Jo said she preferred her first name. I was caught between supporting her request and avoiding an argument with Dad. I told my daughter to use Mrs Clarke for now, which left her being corrected for following the instruction she had actually been given.

Dad prefers a title when children address him. I am happy for my daughter to know that. I do not think his preference should automatically determine what another adult is called.

How do I explain a courtesy rule that can vary with the person, and revisit the moment without making my daughter referee the adults?

Discussion

5 community replies

Tell your daughter that Jo's request was clear and that you changed the instruction because you were uncomfortable with the disagreement. She did not behave disrespectfully by using the name Jo invited her to use.

A workable rule is to use the form of address the person asks for, while checking if you are unsure. That can include a title for one adult and a first name for another. You do not have to teach one format as a universal measure of respect.

Speak with Dad yourself. He can explain how he wants to be addressed without correcting your daughter for honouring another adult's preference. Keep that conversation out of the child's job description.

It would also be courteous to acknowledge Jo directly. She had expressed her preference and then watched the other adults override it. A brief correction does not need to become a family debate in front of her.

Yes. “We should have followed what you asked; she'll call you Jo” would settle the immediate confusion. Then handle Dad's broader objection separately. Your daughter can learn the practical rule without waiting for every adult in the family to agree about all forms of address.

Join the discussion

More in Parenting