Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Parenting · Advice & Questions ·

Should I veto an optional school subject because I think another one keeps more doors open?

Parenting category photographParenting

My fourteen-year-old has chosen art for one of next year's optional subjects. I want her to choose computing instead. When I said she could draw at home, she replied, “I could learn computing at home too.”

The school offers both options, but there is only room for one in her timetable after her other choice. She enjoys art lessons and has looked at the work involved. I am mainly thinking that computing sounds more useful for a future career. We have not checked whether either choice is required for any later course she might consider.

I do not want to pretend every preference has equal consequences. I also cannot name a particular door that her art choice would close. At the moment, my case is mostly a feeling that the more technical-sounding subject must be safer.

How do we make this decision on something firmer than my anxiety or her enthusiasm? I want her to understand the trade-offs, without making her defend a complete career plan at fourteen.

Discussion

5 community replies

Start with the actual courses. What will she study, how will work be assessed and what does the school say about later subject routes? You need those details before “keeps more doors open” can carry much weight.

Take her comparison seriously. If home learning makes art dispensable but computing essential, explain why rather than treating it as backtalk. You may discover that you value the subjects differently without having evidence about this particular timetable.

She does not need to promise an art career to choose an art course. Ask what she wants from the lessons and what she understands about the workload. You can bring future requirements into the discussion without requiring her to predict the job she will eventually want.

Find out whether and when choices can be reviewed, rather than assuming a later switch is either easy or impossible. A school adviser can explain the actual limits. That information belongs in the decision now, not in an “I told you so” conversation later.

Agreed. If changes are restricted, discuss that plainly while looking at both options. If there is a review process, learn how it works without promising a transfer. Her later uncertainty would be a reason to revisit the facts, not automatic proof that you should have vetoed her first choice.

Join the discussion

More in Parenting