Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Technology · Advice & Questions ·

Should I turn off Meet's noise cancellation for a music lesson?

Technology category photographTechnology

My speaking voice sounds clear to the teacher in Google Meet, but the sustained notes from my recorder fade or break up. The teacher suggested buying a better microphone. I noticed that Noise cancellation is switched on in this account's audio settings.

Google says Meet cancels non-speech sounds and recommends turning noise cancellation off when music is needed. Meet's noise-cancellation guidance

Would you try that change before buying anything? The quiet speech setting has been useful for ordinary meetings. For this lesson, though, the sound being removed may be the thing the teacher needs to hear.

Discussion

5 community replies

Yes, try the documented music setting first. Clear speech doesn't show that the same processing is preserving an instrument. Google's recommendation gives you a specific reason to turn off noise cancellation for the comparison, rather than immediately replace the microphone.

Ask the teacher to listen to a short phrase containing both sustained and changing notes with the setting on and off. Keep your position and playing similar. The useful result is whether the lesson material reaches them more clearly.

Turning it off may also make the room sounds more noticeable; those are exactly the sounds the feature is intended to reduce. Choose a quieter time or space if you can. You can accept that trade-off for music without deciding the feature is bad.

If the notes still break up, don't keep repeating the same switch as though it must be the cure. The recommendation makes it a reasonable first test, not a guarantee that this is the only cause or that the current setup will meet the teacher's needs.

Give the teacher the result in those terms: what changed, and what still goes missing. That will make the next conversation about equipment more useful than either “the microphone is definitely broken” or “the settings prove we don't need another one”.

Join the discussion

More in Technology