Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Education · Advice & Questions ·

Should I stop tracing in drawing class if I struggle when the outline is removed?

Education category photographEducation

With the practice sheet underneath, I can draw the cup neatly. Without it, the handle ends up somewhere the cup could never support it.

I'm in a beginners' drawing class. The teacher supplied an outline and explicitly asked us to trace it as one exercise. A classmate called tracing “not real drawing,” which has made me feel that using the sheet at all is something to apologise for.

The later task is to draw a cup from observation. I haven't asked what the tracing exercise is meant to help us notice or how to move from that support to the independent task. I keep making another tidy copy because it feels better than the uneven drawing beside it.

How could I use the exercise purposefully without treating a neat traced outline as proof that I can now draw the object? I want to ask for the missing step, rather than either abandon the teacher's exercise or repeat it indefinitely.

Discussion

5 community replies

Ask the teacher what you should be attending to while tracing and how that connects to the observation task. You have permission for the exercise. The useful question is what you are meant to learn from it, not whether your classmate approves of the tool.

Keep the uneven drawing too. Put it beside the traced version and identify one difference you want help understanding. A specific question about where the handle joins the cup gives the teacher more to work with than 'I can't draw without tracing.'

You could ask to watch the teacher compare the object with one part of the drawing. Then try that part yourself. There is no need to make the next attempt an unsupported test of whether you have suddenly become a good artist.

The tidy copy may be serving a different purpose from the independent drawing. Ask for a small practice task that makes the distinction visible, rather than judge both pages only by which looks better.

For example, the teacher might suggest working on one feature from observation and comparing it afterwards, if that fits the lesson. Keep the question about what you noticed and changed. You do not need to hide the rough attempt just because the supported one would look nicer on display.

Join the discussion

More in Education