Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Technology · Advice & Questions ·

Should I replace my camera because indoor videos show dark bands?

Technology category photographTechnology

The room looks evenly lit to me, but a short video of our model railway has dark bands moving across it. My friend thinks the camera sensor is failing. The bands weren't obvious in a clip taken by the window.

I filmed under the room's electric lights and haven't compared shutter settings. Sony's guidance says changing shutter speed can reduce flicker in stills and movies, with suitable settings depending on the lighting and region. Sony's flicker guidance

The camera is borrowed, so I'd rather not announce that it's damaged on this evidence. What comparison would help separate a lighting interaction from a camera fault before I arrange a repair?

Discussion

5 community replies

Start with the same scene and a short sequence of controlled comparisons: window light, then the room lights, while noting the shutter setting. Changing the room, camera settings and subject all at once would make the result much harder to interpret.

Sony suggests 1/50 or 1/100 second in 50 Hz regions and 1/60 or 1/120 in 60 Hz regions. Treat those as documented starting points, not a guarantee for every lamp. Its guidance also discusses the particular difficulty of some LED lighting.

Tell the owner what you can actually show: banding in this room under these lights. “The sensor has failed” goes beyond that. A sample clip and the settings would give them something useful to assess without making the diagnosis for them.

For the railway film, judge any change with a moving train as well as a still scene. Removing an obvious band is only one part of deciding whether the footage suits the project; the movement still needs to look acceptable to you.

And if one setting looks good, write down the lighting arrangement too. Otherwise the next person may copy the number into a different room and expect the same result. The useful handover is the tested combination, with its limits.

Join the discussion

More in Technology