Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Money · Advice & Questions ·

Should I pay for a valuation before the servicer confirms how my PMI could be removed?

Money category photographMoney

An online estimate says our home has risen in value. A friend suggested paying for a valuation to remove the $70 monthly private mortgage insurance charge on our US conventional mortgage. The possible valuation fee is $400 in this example.

We haven't ordered one. The loan balance is still above 80% of the home's original value, and I don't know whether our servicer offers a separate cancellation route based on current value.

The CFPB distinguishes cancellation rules based on original value from standards a lender or servicer may offer. The applicable loan type and conditions matter.

What would you get confirmed before paying the fee? Six months of possible savings sounds appealing, but only if this valuation is actually part of a route we can use.

Discussion

5 community replies

Ask the servicer which cancellation standard applies to this loan, what conditions you must meet and which valuation process it accepts. An online estimate doesn't answer those questions.

Get the expected cost and who must order the valuation in writing. Paying an independent valuer first could leave you with a report the servicer hasn't agreed to use.

Keep the scheduled cancellation information with the alternative you're exploring. Ask how the dates, eligibility and costs compare before treating a fee as the only way to reduce the charge.

If the servicer confirms a suitable process, does $400 divided by $70 settle whether to proceed?

It gives a simple recovery period of about 5.7 months after cancellation, if it succeeds and those figures hold. Also ask what happens if the valuation is too low or another condition isn't met. The fee may be payable before you know whether the monthly saving will start.

Join the discussion

More in Money