Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Parenting · Advice & Questions ·

Should I let my child replace classmates' drawings to make a group project neater?

Parenting category photographParenting

My ten-year-old brought home the panels for a group poster about a class garden. His job was to arrange them on the backing sheet. Two classmates had drawn and labelled their own sections. He wants to redraw both before sticking them down because their lettering is uneven and their drawings don't match his.

I offered to help him make tidy replacements. My partner asked whether the other children knew we were doing that. They don't; the group won't meet again until the poster is due. My son says he is improving the result and everyone will get the same mark.

We haven't seen a marking guide or asked whether presentation is being assessed. There are no obvious missing sections. I like his care over how it looks, but I can also imagine how he'd feel if his own panel disappeared and someone else's version was submitted under his name.

What should he do with the poster tonight? Can I encourage a good shared result without teaching him that whoever brings the materials home gets to redo everyone else's work?

Discussion

5 community replies

Keep the original panels. Arranging work is the task he brought home; replacing it changes the other children's contribution. He could make a layout that accommodates different styles without deciding on their behalf that those styles need to disappear.

The claim about everyone getting the same mark is worth checking, especially if it's driving the decision. Ask for the actual instructions. Even if there is a shared mark, that doesn't by itself answer what the group agreed he could change.

He can still raise a concrete concern with the group. "This label is hard to read; could we make it larger?" offers a problem to solve together. "I redid yours because mine is neater" leaves them only the choice of accepting the replacement or arguing after it is finished.

Your offer to make replacements may have made his plan sound settled. I'd tell him you spoke before considering that the panels belonged to a shared project, and withdraw that offer. You can help position and attach what the group has already made.

Yes, and if he wants to show a different arrangement, try it with loose pieces before gluing. A reversible layout suggestion is something the group can consider. He doesn't need to erase somebody else's drawing to demonstrate that he has an idea about the whole poster.

Join the discussion

More in Parenting