Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Parenting · Advice & Questions ·

Should I let my child donate all his birthday money when I think he will regret it?

Parenting category photographParenting

My twelve-year-old has £60 from his birthday and wants to donate it all to an animal-rescue appeal. Last week he was saving for a building kit. I said perhaps he should give £5 and keep the rest. He asked why “your money to choose” only applies when I like the choice.

We live in England and would make any online payment together. We have not checked the organisation or the donation page yet. The Charity Commission's safer-giving campaign recommends checking a charity's identity and information before giving financial details.

I am happy to do those checks. My hesitation is that he might want the kit again tomorrow, and the birthday money took several relatives' gifts to reach that total. He says he understands that donating it means waiting longer for the kit.

How do I help him consider the decision without quietly taking it back? I do not want to praise generosity only when it costs an amount I have chosen for him.

Discussion

5 community replies

Ask him to explain what he understands will happen to the £60 and what he will have left for the kit. That is a conversation about the actual choice. It should not become a quiz he must keep answering until he chooses your £5.

Make the online checks together before deciding anything about payment. Use the charity's genuine details and read what the donation page is asking you to authorise, including whether it is a one-off payment. The Charity Commission guidance supports checking rather than feeling pressured to give immediately.

I would allow a short pause that has a purpose: time to verify the appeal and think about the competing plans. Tell him when you will return to it. “We will see” repeated indefinitely would leave him technically owning the money but unable to use it.

Could you accept that a considered decision might still lead to some regret? You cannot guarantee he will never wish he had bought the kit. If the essentials are covered and the payment is properly checked, disappointment later would not by itself prove the donation was a bad choice.

That is the part the parent needs to decide honestly. If he later misses the kit, you can sympathise without replacing the donated money or saying “I warned you.” Equally, he does not have to keep declaring himself delighted with the donation to defend the permission you gave.

Join the discussion

More in Parenting