Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Entertainment · Advice & Questions ·

Should I keep a prize when we agreed to pool arcade tickets and I earned most of them?

Entertainment category photographEntertainment

I had enough prize tickets for the model I'd wanted when we arrived. Then I remembered we'd agreed to combine everyone's tickets for one gift for our birthday friend.

Four of us spent the afternoon at an arcade. Before playing, we chose the shared gift as our plan. I happened to earn most of the tickets, and the others earned fewer than they'd expected. We'd each paid for our own play.

At the prize counter, I suggested keeping some back for myself. Another friend said that would leave us short of the gift. I could hear how the change sounded after the results were known, even though part of me felt the larger contribution should count.

What should I do with the agreement we actually made? I'd like to be honest about wanting the model without rewriting the afternoon's plan only because the outcome favoured me.

Discussion

5 community replies

The agreement was to pool what you earned, without a condition about who contributed most. You can recognise the larger contribution and still follow the plan you chose before playing.

Wanting the model isn't something you need to disguise. It just doesn't answer why everyone else should accept a new arrangement after finding out who earned what.

Don't make the birthday friend choose whether to release you from the gift. That would hand them the awkward decision about something the group had already offered to do.

If another friend had earned most of the tickets, would you have wanted the pooling agreement to stand? That is a useful check on the exception you're now proposing.

That keeps the comparison about the agreement, rather than which friend cares most about the birthday gift. You can feel the pull of the model without making anyone else prove their generosity.

Join the discussion

More in Entertainment