Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Parenting · Advice & Questions ·

Should I insist on chapter books when my child chooses graphic novels for pleasure?

Parenting category photographParenting

At the library, my ten-year-old used all three of his loans on graphic novels. I told him one should be a “real reading book.” He opened the first one and asked which part did not count.

He reads the books assigned at school. These were his choices for home. My concern is that he will never choose longer prose if I do not insist on it, but I have turned that worry into a rule that every library trip must include a book he has not asked for.

I like reading with him and would enjoy sharing some stories I loved. He is now suspicious that any recommendation is an attempt to replace the books he chose.

How can I offer a wider range without making his pleasure reading something he must earn by doing the kind I approve of first?

Discussion

5 community replies

Correct “real reading book.” It was a judgment about his choice, and his question was fair. You can say you meant a book with longer prose without implying that his graphic novels are counterfeit books.

Ask him to show you what he likes about one of the books he borrowed. It might be the story, the pictures, the humour or the series. Listen before using the answer to recommend something else; the conversation can simply be about the book he is enjoying.

Your wish to share an old favourite is reasonable. Offer to read a little together if he wants, or borrow it yourself so it is available. Present it as an invitation rather than an extra item he must finish before returning to his own choices.

Keep school tasks and home preferences clear. If there is an actual assignment to read a particular kind of text, help him meet that assignment. Do not invent a school requirement to lend authority to your own library rule.

Yes. In this account he is already doing the assigned reading, so the library question is about what freedom you give his leisure choices. You can keep offering different books without making every borrowing trip a test of whether he has finally moved toward your favourites.

Join the discussion

More in Parenting