Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Education · Advice & Questions ·

Should I insist on a new bedtime book when my child keeps choosing the same favourite?

Education category photographEducation

“The one with the missing hat,” my son said. It has been the one with the missing hat almost every night this week.

He's six. We do his school reading separately, and bedtime is when I usually read aloud. He joins in with the familiar lines, anticipates the joke and complains if I use the wrong voice. I have started suggesting a different book because I worry that we are repeating instead of moving on.

There are other books available, and he sometimes enjoys one once we begin. But when I make a new story the condition for hearing his favourite, the choosing takes longer than the reading.

How could I make room for variety without turning the familiar story into something he has to earn? I want to keep sharing books enjoyable and understand what I am trying to change. At the moment I may be more tired of the hat than he is.

Discussion

5 community replies

Keep the two purposes clear: you already have a separate school-reading task, and bedtime is shared reading aloud. You do not have to make every evening's story prove that he has moved to something harder.

BookTrust's reading tips explicitly reassure parents about children rereading the same book and encourage continued shared reading. That is permission to relax the novelty requirement, not a reason to assume memorised lines demonstrate every reading skill.

You could offer a short new story alongside the favourite when there is time, or let him browse alternatives without making choosing one compulsory. Treat it as something to try, rather than another rule he has to pass before the hat appears.

Your enjoyment matters too. It is reasonable to say you would like a turn choosing sometimes, while leaving him regular opportunities to choose the familiar book. You do not need to justify your preference as a concern about his development.

A shared choosing arrangement could make that honest: some nights his pick, some nights yours, if that works for both of you. If you choose a new book, it can simply be because you want to share it. The favourite has not failed a progress test.

Join the discussion

More in Education