Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Education · Advice & Questions ·

Should I insist my daughter stays in the school club after the trial we agreed has ended?

Education category photographEducation

I persuaded my daughter to try the debating club for four sessions. She has attended all four and now wants her lunch break back for drawing with a friend.

I said she could decide after trying it. At the time I expected her to enjoy it, so agreeing was easy. Now I want to say she should stay until the end of term. Part of that is wanting her to try unfamiliar things; part is that I would feel awkward telling the teacher we are stopping. No upcoming match has been mentioned to me.

How do I discuss this without making the trial mean 'until you give me the answer I wanted'?

Discussion

5 community replies

She completed the trial you proposed. Before making another case for the club, acknowledge that you offered her a decision and are now tempted to change its terms.

What is wrong with drawing at lunchtime in this particular situation? If the concern is simply that she is quiet, consider whether you have made her preferred break sound like a problem she must solve.

Ask what she made of the four sessions without turning every answer into a reason to stay. She might have disliked debating, the group, or losing that time with her friend; those are different conversations.

Check whether she has accepted a specific responsibility you do not know about. Leaving the club and leaving someone expecting her at a particular event would need different arrangements.

Tell her what you are checking before contacting the teacher. If there is a commitment to resolve, discuss that exact commitment with her; it should not silently become a fresh requirement to attend for the rest of term.

Join the discussion

More in Education