Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Entertainment · Advice & Questions ·

Should I have stopped our band's song after I missed my entrance?

Entertainment category photographEntertainment

At our band's first informal set for friends, I came in a bar late on guitar. The drummer and singer kept going. I stopped playing, waved at them to stop too and said into the microphone that we should start again.

The second attempt went better for me. Afterwards the singer said the first version was still recoverable and that my restart had turned my mistake into a break for the whole band. I said I didn't want our first performance to sound careless. She replied, "Then you needed to listen to what the rest of us were doing."

We had rehearsed the song but never discussed who could call a restart. I wasn't trying to take charge; in the moment I wanted to erase the bad beginning. Should I apologise for stopping us, or is asking for a clean start reasonable when everyone knows we're beginners?

Discussion

5 community replies

Apologise for making the decision for everyone while they were still playing. You can do that without pretending your missed entrance felt fine. The singer's point seems to be about the choice you made after the mistake, rather than the mistake itself.

A clean second attempt matters to you, but the others had already committed to the first one. Your restart asked them to abandon their recovery so you could have yours. That is worth recognising before debating which version sounded better.

Did anyone have an agreed role leading the set? If so, talk about what signal they wanted you to follow. If no one did, this is a good rehearsal problem: deliberately miss an entry and try getting back in together, then agree when a stop would be useful.

Being beginners is a reason to make room for mistakes, including your panicked restart. It needn't become a judgement about whether you're fit to perform. A brief apology and an agreed approach would be more useful than spending the next rehearsal prosecuting that one bar.

And the agreed approach needn't be "never stop under any circumstances." Decide what the group wants to do when someone gets lost, who makes the call, and how the others recognise it. That gives you something to practise instead of simply being told to panic less.

Join the discussion

More in Entertainment