Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Education · Advice & Questions ·

Should I give up a school orchestra place because my friend did not get in?

Education category photographEducation

My friend helped me practise for the audition. I got a school orchestra place and she did not. When I told her, she said, “I suppose our Tuesday lunches are over, then.”

Tuesday lunch is our usual time together, and it is now a rehearsal slot. She has not asked me to turn the place down, but I have started thinking that accepting it would be disloyal. I was excited before this conversation; now I keep drafting a message to the music teacher saying I cannot join.

How do I talk to her before deciding? I want to take the opportunity, and I also understand that the change costs her something. Promising that nothing between us will change would not be true.

Discussion

5 community replies

Her comment may be about losing Tuesday lunch as well as the audition result. Ask what she is most upset about before treating it as a demand that you withdraw. She has not actually made that request.

You can say you want to accept the place and will miss that time together. Those can both be true. Acknowledging her disappointment does not require you to hide your own excitement or apologise for auditioning successfully.

Look at the real rehearsal schedule before offering another regular meeting. A small arrangement you can keep would be kinder than promising to make every lost lunchtime up and then repeatedly cancelling.

If you decide to decline, make sure it is a choice you want to make, rather than a sacrifice you expect her to repay. Giving up your place would not automatically mean that she receives it.

If you withdraw, let the teacher handle the place under the orchestra's process. Do not offer your friend an outcome you cannot arrange. Talk about what each of you wants from the friendship before making a decision in its name.

Join the discussion

More in Education