Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Education · Advice & Questions ·

Should I enter a student competition mainly to get detailed feedback?

Education category photographEducation

The college poster competition closes the same week as my report is due. I have an idea I want to try, and I was treating the competition as a chance to have someone explain what works and what does not.

Then I reread the announcement. It explains how the shortlist and winner will be announced, but says nothing about comments for every entrant. I have not asked the organiser. I could spend most of the weekend making the poster and still receive only a result.

How should I weigh the entry against my coursework? Winning would be welcome, but the detailed feedback is what made the extra work seem worthwhile to me.

Discussion

5 community replies

Ask the organiser what feedback, if any, entrants receive and whether it differs for shortlisted work. Judging a competition and providing individual critique are different activities; the announcement you describe promises only the result.

Consider whether making and submitting the poster would still be worth the time without written comments. You might value testing the idea or meeting the brief. If those are not enough for you, do not quietly substitute them for the benefit you wanted.

Look at what the report still needs before giving the weekend to a new poster. Decide how much competition work you can afford in that schedule, rather than make the entry first and hope the coursework fits around it.

You could also ask about a small, agreed opportunity for feedback outside the competition, such as a workshop review of one draft. Keep the request bounded and check that someone is available; do not assume the course tutor can add a full critique at short notice.

If that review is possible, it may answer the need that made the competition attractive. Decide about entering separately, with the actual feedback arrangements and your remaining coursework time in view. An unconfirmed hope for comments should not carry the whole decision.

Join the discussion

More in Education