Should I change an old book rating after a reread gave me a different opinion?
EntertainmentMy old review called the novel a favourite and gave it five stars. After rereading it this month, I'd give it three. A friend said changing the rating would erase an honest record of what the book once meant to me.
The original review was sincere. I loved the friendship in it at the time. This time the same scenes felt less convincing, though there were passages I still enjoyed. I haven't discovered a factual error in my review or learned anything new about the author. My response to the novel has changed.
I use the page both to record my reading and to recommend books to friends. Leaving five stars feels inaccurate as a current recommendation; replacing the whole review feels inaccurate as a history.
Would you keep both responses with dates, revise the rating with a note, or leave the old review alone? I'm trying to represent a changed opinion without pretending the first one was foolish or false.