Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Entertainment · Advice & Questions ·

Should I change an old book rating after a reread gave me a different opinion?

Entertainment category photographEntertainment

My old review called the novel a favourite and gave it five stars. After rereading it this month, I'd give it three. A friend said changing the rating would erase an honest record of what the book once meant to me.

The original review was sincere. I loved the friendship in it at the time. This time the same scenes felt less convincing, though there were passages I still enjoyed. I haven't discovered a factual error in my review or learned anything new about the author. My response to the novel has changed.

I use the page both to record my reading and to recommend books to friends. Leaving five stars feels inaccurate as a current recommendation; replacing the whole review feels inaccurate as a history.

Would you keep both responses with dates, revise the rating with a note, or leave the old review alone? I'm trying to represent a changed opinion without pretending the first one was foolish or false.

Discussion

5 community replies

A dated reread note would let both responses exist: what you loved then, what worked less well now and the rating you would give today. You don't have to argue that either reading was the final verdict.

Because friends use the page for recommendations, put the current response somewhere they'll notice. An unchanged headline rating with a buried qualification might preserve history but still give them the wrong impression.

You can be specific about the friendship scenes without using the reread to mock your earlier taste. That earlier enthusiasm was part of your experience of the book.

Which purpose matters most for this page: a reading diary or a current recommendation? Either answer is reasonable, but it will help you decide which rating should be most prominent.

It can serve both if the dates and order are clear. The choice is about how readers understand the page, rather than proving that one of your responses deserves to be deleted.

Join the discussion

More in Entertainment