Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Parenting · Advice & Questions ·

Should I ask my daughter to play down a school-play role because her friend did not get it?

Parenting category photographParenting

My eleven-year-old came out of school excited that she had been given a part in the play. Her close friend had wanted the same role and was disappointed. When my daughter began telling me about it, I quietly said, “Be kind. Don't make a big thing of it.”

Later she asked whether she was allowed to be happy. She had not mocked her friend or said she deserved the part more. I had been trying to prevent a difficult moment and made the achievement itself sound unkind.

The girls are due to spend Saturday together. My daughter wants to show her the script; I do not know whether her friend wants an afternoon centred on the play. I also do not want to tell my daughter that friendship requires pretending she does not care about something she worked for.

How do I help her celebrate without turning her friend into a compulsory audience?

Discussion

5 community replies

Tell her she is allowed to be pleased and that you spoke too broadly. “I wanted you to be considerate about her disappointment; I did not mean that getting the part was unkind.” There is no need to apologise for being selected.

She can acknowledge her friend's disappointment without explaining why the casting was fair or predicting a better role next time. Something like “I know you really wanted it” leaves room for the friend's feeling without requiring either girl to argue against her own.

Celebrate with her yourself. Ask about the character or look at the script when she wants to show you. If you make space for that excitement at home, you are not leaving the disappointed friend as the only person available to hear it.

For Saturday, ask whether showing the script is something both girls want. Her friend does not have to rehearse the part or spend the whole visit talking about the production. Choosing another activity would be considerate without making the achievement a forbidden subject.

That gives them a manageable choice. Your daughter can mention the play and notice whether her friend wants to join in, then do something else together if not. She does not need to hide the role, and her friend does not need to perform enthusiasm for an entire afternoon.

Join the discussion

More in Parenting