Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Parenting · Advice & Questions ·

Should I allow a branded school bag if my teenager pays the difference?

Parenting category photographParenting

We set aside £30 for my thirteen-year-old's replacement school bag because the zip on his old one has broken. He chose one costing £70 and offered £40 from his gift money. I said I would pay for a bag he needs, not a logo. He replied, “You still only pay £30.”

Those are the figures for the two options we are considering, not a recommended school-bag budget. He has enough saved for the difference. We have not yet compared the bags' capacity or checked whether the school has any restrictions.

I think the brand is poor value. He says he likes it and wants to make the choice with his own money. MoneyHelper's guidance for teenagers includes planning purchases around their expenses and savings goals.

How much should my opinion count after we have agreed what I can contribute? I do not want to promise spending freedom and then reject every choice I would not make myself.

Discussion

5 community replies

Check the practical requirements first: does the bag hold what he needs, is it suitable for the school and are the two options being compared on more than the logo? Those questions can reveal a real objection or show that your remaining objection is mainly taste.

His arithmetic is right within the arrangement described. That does not settle every purchase question, but it means “I am not spending £70 on a logo” would misstate what he is asking you to pay.

Ask what using the £40 would leave for his other plans. MoneyHelper suggests thinking about expenses and savings goals. You can help him make that trade-off without requiring him to conclude that the logo is a waste.

If you are not willing to offer advances or replace the gift money later, say so before he buys. That is different from threatening to withdraw the basic £30 because he has asked for an upgrade.

Agreed. The needed school bag still needs a practical plan. He can choose an option within your contribution or, if the bag is suitable and you permit it, add his own money. Clear terms beforehand are more useful than making a future “I wish I had saved that £40” an occasion to punish the original preference.

Join the discussion

More in Parenting