Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Parenting · Advice & Questions ·

Should I advance allowance when my child says borrowing is a skill adults use too?

Parenting category photographParenting

My twelve-year-old has saved most of the cost of a model kit and wants several weeks of allowance early for the rest. I said saving meant waiting. He pointed to my credit card and asked why borrowing was sensible for me but a bad habit for him.

We could afford an advance, but I haven't decided whether to offer one. The CFPB's guidance on talking with school-age children about borrowing uses credit cards to discuss repayment and encourages adults to explain their own approach. It doesn't decide our family allowance arrangement for us.

My partner thinks a clear advance could teach planning. I worry we'll reach the next activity he wants to pay for and find that the money has already been spent. What would you settle before saying yes? I'd like an honest discussion of what an advance would mean without turning waiting into proof of virtue or borrowing into money with no later consequence.

Discussion

5 community replies

First decide whether you mean an advance, an extra gift or a refusal. Calling an extra gift an advance and quietly ignoring it later would leave the arrangement harder to understand than a straightforward yes or no.

Show which future allowance payments would already have been brought forward. He can consider what those weeks would look like without choosing an exact prediction of every future purchase. The point is that the same spending money won't become available a second time.

Answer the credit-card comparison honestly in terms you can substantiate about your own use. It isn't enough to say adults are different. Equally, explaining your repayment plan doesn't oblige you to provide the same borrowing arrangement for every request.

Talk about what happens if another optional activity comes up before the advance has been covered. That is the moment you are worried about, so don't leave it as an unstated future test of whether he remembers the agreement.

And choose an arrangement you are willing to follow yourself. If you already know you'd treat the next request as a fresh gift, be honest about that rather than approving an advance whose repayment period exists only until the next disappointment.

Join the discussion

More in Parenting