Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Technology · Advice & Questions ·

Should beginners type every line of code during a one-hour workshop?

Technology category photographTechnology

The exercise is to make a button change a message. My co-host wants everyone to type the starter code because “copying isn't learning”. I prepared a starter file so people could spend more time changing the message and understanding what happens.

In our rehearsal, a missing quote took us away from the button's behaviour for several minutes. The co-host sees that as a useful lesson. I can see the value, but the session has an hour and some people will still be finding the editor.

Would you combine a prepared start with a small piece they type themselves? I want them to leave having changed something they understand, with room to ask why it works.

Discussion

5 community replies

A starter file doesn't prevent learning if the exercise asks people to predict, change and explain its behaviour. I'd use it to get everyone to the same starting point, then give them a meaningful small change to make.

The co-host's concern is fair: someone can copy a working example without understanding any of it. Make the explanation part of the activity instead of treating successful copying or successful typing as proof that the idea is understood.

Choose which syntax problem the hour is meant to teach. One deliberate small edit can reveal why quotation marks matter without making every beginner reconstruct the entire starter file under time pressure.

Offer the full typing exercise afterwards for people who want it, while keeping the live session's main route clear. The optional material can serve a different aim without becoming another compulsory block at the end.

Give that material the same starting and expected outcomes as the workshop version. Someone trying it later should know what they're building and where to compare their result, rather than receive an unexplained wall of code after everyone has gone home.

Join the discussion

More in Technology