Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Technology · Advice & Questions ·

Should an OBS recording include a combined listening track as well as separate microphone tracks?

Technology category photographTechnology

We assigned two speakers' microphones to separate recording tracks in OBS so a future editor could adjust them independently. I then proposed sending the recording straight to the speakers for review. In the video player, I heard only one voice at a time when switching audio tracks.

OBS's guide distinguishes separate tracks for editing from a combined track for ordinary playback. OBS's multiple-track guide

Should we record a combined mix as well, or expect every recipient to assemble the tracks? I want to preserve editing flexibility without giving people an awkward first version of their own conversation.

Discussion

5 community replies

Separate audio tracks aren't normally played together by an ordinary video player. OBS's guide recommends sending all sources to track 1 for a listening mix, with additional tracks used to keep sources separate for editing.

Your original plan has a useful purpose: an editor may want individual voices. It just doesn't automatically produce the review experience you promised the speakers. Those two deliverables can have different needs.

For the existing recording, inspect the tracks and prepare a listening version if both voices were captured. Don't assume that selecting one track in a player should somehow make the other voice join it.

Tell the speakers which file is the version they should review, and keep the editable source material clearly identified for the editor. They shouldn't have to infer the intended workflow from several nearly identical filenames.

Give them a version in which they can assess the conversation as a conversation, including interruptions and responses. Asking each person to listen only to their isolated voice wouldn't answer the same editorial questions.

Join the discussion

More in Technology