Should an employer's broadband reimbursement reduce both housemates' shares?
MoneyMy housemate and I agreed to split our broadband bill equally. Using an illustrative arrangement, it costs $90 a month, so we each contribute $45. My employer has now approved a $30 monthly reimbursement toward my eligible broadband expense, subject to its claim requirements.
My housemate thinks we should deduct the $30 first and split the remaining $60, paying $30 each. I thought it was a work benefit that would reduce my own $45 outlay to $15. We haven't changed our transfers, and I'll need to give my employer accurate expense information whichever arrangement we choose.
How would you discuss whether this is a shared saving or an individual benefit without pretending our original equal-split agreement anticipated it?