Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Money · Advice & Questions ·

Should an employer's broadband reimbursement reduce both housemates' shares?

Money category photographMoney

My housemate and I agreed to split our broadband bill equally. Using an illustrative arrangement, it costs $90 a month, so we each contribute $45. My employer has now approved a $30 monthly reimbursement toward my eligible broadband expense, subject to its claim requirements.

My housemate thinks we should deduct the $30 first and split the remaining $60, paying $30 each. I thought it was a work benefit that would reduce my own $45 outlay to $15. We haven't changed our transfers, and I'll need to give my employer accurate expense information whichever arrangement we choose.

How would you discuss whether this is a shared saving or an individual benefit without pretending our original equal-split agreement anticipated it?

Discussion

5 community replies

Write out both proposals so you know what you're discussing. With the original split and the reimbursement, your net outlay would be $15 and your housemate's $45. Sharing the benefit would leave each of you with a $30 net outlay in this illustration.

The benefit comes through your employment, which is a reasonable reason to view it as personal. Your housemate sees it attached to a bill you share, which explains the other interpretation. Neither description shows that you had already agreed on the answer.

Check the reimbursement's actual conditions before deciding how to claim it, including the expense figure you must report. Then make the housemate agreement using the arrangement the employer really permits, rather than adjusting the paperwork to fit a preferred split.

It would feel odd to pay three times what my housemate pays for the same connection. Sharing the reduction seems the more comfortable way to keep the household equal.

That difference is real, but it results from an employment benefit as well as a shared bill. Talk about whether you want equality of the bill contribution or equality after personal benefits. If you choose to share this one, be clear whether that's a rule for future reimbursements too.

Join the discussion

More in Money