Should a rehearsal recording keep the mistakes if we're using it to practise?
EntertainmentOur hobby band recorded a rehearsal so we could listen between sessions. A bandmate cleaned up the audio before sending it round. He also copied a clean chorus over the one where we lost the entry.
I thanked him for the sound, then realised I couldn't hear the mistake I wanted to work on. He said listening to the correct version would be more helpful than replaying the messy one. We hadn't agreed whether this was meant to be a model of the song or a record of how we'd actually played.
I don't know whether he kept the untouched recording, and I haven't asked yet. I want to appreciate his effort while explaining why a tidier track isn't necessarily the practice aid I was expecting.