Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Entertainment · Advice & Questions ·

Should a rehearsal recording keep the mistakes if we're using it to practise?

Entertainment category photographEntertainment

Our hobby band recorded a rehearsal so we could listen between sessions. A bandmate cleaned up the audio before sending it round. He also copied a clean chorus over the one where we lost the entry.

I thanked him for the sound, then realised I couldn't hear the mistake I wanted to work on. He said listening to the correct version would be more helpful than replaying the messy one. We hadn't agreed whether this was meant to be a model of the song or a record of how we'd actually played.

I don't know whether he kept the untouched recording, and I haven't asked yet. I want to appreciate his effort while explaining why a tidier track isn't necessarily the practice aid I was expecting.

Discussion

5 community replies

Ask whether an untouched version is available, and explain the specific chorus you wanted to hear. Don't assume he can restore something he may not have kept. For future sessions, agree the purpose before anyone spends time editing.

He has made something closer to a model, while you wanted a record of the rehearsal. Both could have uses. The disagreement doesn't need to be settled by declaring that either polished or messy recordings are always more helpful.

If the original isn't available, you can still tell him where the difference matters to you and agree what to record next time. Keep the request grounded in what he actually has, rather than assuming he can recreate the missing performance.

What are the other members using the recording for? Some may want to learn the structure, while others want to hear their own entries. Finding that out could help you choose what the group actually wants to keep.

If the needs differ, you could discuss keeping an unaltered reference alongside any edited version, where that is practical and agreed. That doesn't mean he has automatically volunteered to produce two mixes every week. Decide the useful minimum together.

Join the discussion

More in Entertainment