Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Gaming · Advice & Questions ·

Should a recognisable spelling mistake cost us a point at a casual trivia night?

Gaming category photographGaming

We wrote 'Jupitr' on a planet question at a friend's trivia night. The host knew we meant Jupiter but withheld the point because the spelling was wrong. Earlier they'd accepted a misspelled answer from another team, and I'd agreed it was obvious what that team meant.

There were no prizes, but our team finished one point behind. I mentioned the earlier answer and the host said the two mistakes felt different. I couldn't explain a general rule either; I mostly wanted our answer treated generously now that it affected us.

How would you discuss a consistent approach for the next quiz without reopening every answer from this one? I can live with stricter marking if we know what is being tested.

Discussion

5 community replies

A useful distinction is whether the written answer unambiguously identifies the intended answer or could mean something else. That's a possible marking convention to agree beforehand, rather than something your team gets to declare after losing.

It's useful that you've noticed how much the missing point matters to you. Keep the request about a convention everyone can use, rather than presenting your frustration as proof that the host was unfair.

If spelling is itself the challenge on a particular question, the host should make that clear. The group can choose that kind of round without treating every general-knowledge answer as a spelling test.

The host also needs room to make ordinary judgment calls. A short convention and a way to query an answer once may be more workable than making them defend every near miss for ten minutes.

Agreed. Consistency doesn't have to mean an appeals court over 'Jupitr.' Settle the convention for future rounds, and allow an ambiguous case to be resolved without implying the host favours someone's team.

Join the discussion

More in Gaming