Should a pupil get to choose which of her drawings goes on our classroom wall?
EducationI chose a pupil's careful pencil portrait for the class display. She asked me to use her newer ink drawing instead. It has heavier marks and a less tidy outline, but she says it looks more like what she meant.
I told her the pencil one was more finished. Afterwards I realised that I had not explained what the display was meant to show. I was also choosing pieces that looked good together on the wall. Neither drawing is being graded for this display.
How much of this choice should belong to her? I want to make thoughtful selections without teaching her that liking her own work matters only when I agree.