Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Education · Advice & Questions ·

Should a pupil get to choose which of her drawings goes on our classroom wall?

Education category photographEducation

I chose a pupil's careful pencil portrait for the class display. She asked me to use her newer ink drawing instead. It has heavier marks and a less tidy outline, but she says it looks more like what she meant.

I told her the pencil one was more finished. Afterwards I realised that I had not explained what the display was meant to show. I was also choosing pieces that looked good together on the wall. Neither drawing is being graded for this display.

How much of this choice should belong to her? I want to make thoughtful selections without teaching her that liking her own work matters only when I agree.

Discussion

5 community replies

Decide what the wall is for before defending the selection. A display of a particular drawing task and a display of pupils' chosen work would give you different reasons to select a piece.

She has given you a reason beyond 'I like this one'. Ask her to show you what the heavier marks express. That conversation might change your selection, even if it does not settle it automatically.

If there is room, could the two portraits be shown together with her explanation? Only offer that if it is a real option, rather than a way to postpone saying whose choice this will be.

'More finished' has become the verdict without an explained criterion. Tell her what you noticed in the pencil portrait, and let her explain what she considers deliberate in the ink one.

You may discover that a line you treated as unfinished was a choice she wanted to keep. If the pencil portrait still better fits the display's purpose, explain that purpose specifically; do not make your preference stand in for a general judgment of her newer work.

Join the discussion

More in Education