Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Money · Advice & Questions ·

Should a punishment take away chore money my child has already earned?

Money category photographMoney

We agreed to pay my 13-year-old $12 for cleaning the outside chairs. The job was finished and checked on Saturday. Before I paid, we argued on Sunday about a separate broken screen-time rule.

I said, 'Then you can forget the twelve dollars.' My child replied that I was changing the deal after the work was done.

I want the screen-time rule to matter. I also want paid jobs to mean what we agreed. The $12 wasn't a reward for a whole week of good behaviour; we attached it to one completed task.

Would you pay the money and address the rule separately, or can withholding it be a reasonable consequence? I need a way to correct my reaction without pretending the later argument didn't happen.

Discussion

5 community replies

Your description gives the payment a clear trigger: completed work that you had already checked. Paying that $12 would follow the agreement you made, rather than approve of what happened on Sunday.

You can say, 'I mixed two things together when I was angry. The job payment stands; we still need to address screen time.' That correction leaves the second conversation open.

If you want future arrangements to include other conditions, explain them before anyone accepts the work. Consider whether you actually want a task payment or a broader behaviour reward.

Would paying immediately make the child think arguing successfully can cancel a consequence?

Explain what changed: you reconsidered a consequence that contradicted the job agreement. You haven't promised that every consequence disappears after an objection. Then choose a response to the actual screen-time issue that you can explain on its own terms.

Join the discussion

More in Money