Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Entertainment · Advice & Questions ·

People keep comparing my writing to an author I haven't read

Entertainment category photographEntertainment

At a workshop, two people compared a story of mine to the work of a famous novelist. I smiled as though I understood the connection. Afterwards, one asked which of that novelist's books had influenced me, and I admitted I hadn't read any.

She seemed surprised and said I really should before continuing this project. Now I feel I need to complete someone else's reading list before I'm allowed to revise my own story. I am curious about the comparison, but I don't even know whether they meant the sentences, the plot or the atmosphere.

I would like to ask what they noticed without turning the next workshop into a confession about the gaps in my reading.

Discussion

5 community replies

Ask exactly that: "When you made the comparison, what part of the story were you thinking of?" A specific answer could be useful feedback. The author's name on its own doesn't tell you what to keep or reconsider.

You already admitted you hadn't read the books. You don't have to repeat the admission as a warning before discussing your own draft. It is possible to be interested in a comparison without claiming it as an influence.

If you want to read the novelist, choose a book because the connection interests you. You don't need to accept an unspecified reading list as a condition of making your next revision.

The initial smile is the only part you might want to handle differently next time. "I haven't read them; what feels similar?" would have kept the conversation open immediately. That isn't a demand to know every reference before attending a workshop.

Yes, and that question gives the other person a more useful job than testing whether you recognise a name. They may be able to explain the resemblance clearly, or discover that they were reaching for a loose association. Either is better than you having to guess.

Join the discussion

More in Entertainment