Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Entertainment · Advice & Questions ·

Our zine editor says Creative Commons means we can leave the image credit out

Entertainment category photographEntertainment

I'm laying out a free fan zine with a friend. We found an illustration on the artist's own page marked CC BY 4.0. I cropped it for a half-page feature and left room for a credit. My friend removed that line because the page looked cleaner, saying, "It's Creative Commons. The artist has already said anyone can use it."

I checked the CC BY 4.0 terms. They require appropriate credit, a licence link and an indication of changes. The summary also says the licence may not cover every permission a particular use needs.

We haven't distributed the zine. I want to check the supplied attribution details and restore a suitable credit, including the crop, before we do. My friend says I'm turning a friendly free project into paperwork. How do I explain that being allowed to use an image doesn't mean I can ignore the conditions, without pretending I can give the whole zine a legal clearance?

Discussion

5 community replies

Her conclusion skips the condition attached to the permission. Under CC BY 4.0, giving appropriate credit, linking the licence and indicating modifications are part of using the material on those terms. A free zine doesn't make those conditions disappear.

Show her a layout with the credit included rather than arguing only about the empty line. There may be a readable design that satisfies the attribution requirements and still looks good. The artist's name doesn't have to be treated as a blemish to hide.

Check the information supplied with that particular illustration, including the original link and any notices. The licence label alone isn't a complete attribution you can paste under every image. If you're unsure about a necessary permission, resolve it or choose material you can use with confidence.

You can take responsibility for the crop you made without accepting responsibility for certifying every contribution to the zine. "I'll sort out this image's attribution; we should each check what we've supplied" is a manageable division of work.

That division also avoids the unhelpful leap from "this credit is needed" to "you must be our lawyer now." You're raising an identifiable issue on an undistributed page. It can be fixed without making a claim that every other aspect has been professionally checked.

Join the discussion

More in Entertainment