Our weekly racing challenge allows unlimited retries. Would an attempt limit be fairer?
GamingOur friends post their best lap on the same track each week, with as many attempts as they want before Sunday. I usually get one evening to try. One friend spends several evenings improving their time and is now well ahead.
I suggested an attempt limit, and they said practising is part of why the challenge is fun. They are following the arrangement we made. I'm not questioning their result; I'm questioning whether the comparison is giving me the kind of shared challenge I wanted.
Would you keep the open board, propose a separate limited-attempt session, or change the next challenge? I want my available time to feel worthwhile without pretending my friend's extra effort is an unfair advantage they should have known not to use.