Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Gaming · Advice & Questions ·

Our weekly racing challenge allows unlimited retries. Would an attempt limit be fairer?

Gaming category photographGaming

Our friends post their best lap on the same track each week, with as many attempts as they want before Sunday. I usually get one evening to try. One friend spends several evenings improving their time and is now well ahead.

I suggested an attempt limit, and they said practising is part of why the challenge is fun. They are following the arrangement we made. I'm not questioning their result; I'm questioning whether the comparison is giving me the kind of shared challenge I wanted.

Would you keep the open board, propose a separate limited-attempt session, or change the next challenge? I want my available time to feel worthwhile without pretending my friend's extra effort is an unfair advantage they should have known not to use.

Discussion

5 community replies

Keep the current result under the terms everyone entered. You can propose a different format for a later challenge without discounting a time set fairly under this one.

What do you most want to compare: everyone's best eventual lap, or what each can do in an agreed short session? An attempt limit changes the activity rather than simply making the existing one fair in every sense.

Your one evening can still have a goal that isn't first place. If you enjoy improving your own lap, the open board may remain useful even when another player's total practice is much greater.

A limited-attempt event could sit alongside the open challenge if enough people actually want to take part. Ask before giving the organiser another result sheet to maintain.

And keep that second format optional. It wouldn't help much if trying to make the challenge fit your week quietly made everyone else's week more demanding.

Join the discussion

More in Gaming