Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Weddings · Advice & Questions ·

Our wedding's only starter is raw oysters. How do we add another option without singling out a pregnant guest?

Weddings category photographWeddings

At our US wedding tasting, the caterer presented an oyster bar as the starter for everyone. My bridesmaid later asked privately whether there would be a cooked alternative because she is pregnant. When I asked the caterer, he said the oysters would be fresh and kept on ice, as though that answered her question.

The FDA's pregnancy food-safety guidance advises avoiding raw or undercooked seafood, including oysters. Freshness and chilling don't turn a raw oyster into a cooked alternative. I don't want to send my friend's name or medical circumstances around the planning group to explain why the menu needs another choice.

My partner loves the oyster bar and thinks an extra starter for her would settle it. I'd rather offer a properly described cooked option to anyone who wants it, but that could mean changing the package we chose. How do we ask for a workable alternative without treating the bridesmaid as the person making our dinner more complicated?

Discussion

5 community replies

The caterer answered a storage question you weren't asking. Bring it back to the menu: “We need a cooked starter option and accurate descriptions of both choices. What can you provide within our package, and what would a change cost?”

Your bridesmaid told you privately for a reason. You can request another option without naming her or explaining a pregnancy. Ask what information she wants passed to the catering contact if she has any additional requirements; don't decide that on her behalf.

There may be guests who simply dislike oysters, too. Offering a choice doesn't have to be announced as a special accommodation. Keep the raw description clear so nobody has to infer how the oysters are prepared from an attractive station name.

Would your partner prefer keeping the oyster bar as an optional extra rather than making it everyone's starter? Ask the caterer to price that version alongside a different shared starter. You may have more than the choice between cancelling the bar and creating one exceptional plate.

That comparison would help, provided the alternative arrives as part of the same course. If guests choosing it have to leave the room or wait while everyone else eats, the extra option hasn't really solved the hosting problem. Ask about service as well as the dish.

Join the discussion

More in Weddings