Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Housing · Advice & Questions ·

Our Texas home-insurance quote has a percentage wind-and-hail deductible. A percentage of what?

Housing category photographHousing

We are comparing home-insurance quotes for our house in Texas. One has a lower annual premium and a wind-and-hail deductible shown as a percentage. My partner thinks that means we would pay that percentage of a repair bill, so he sees it as a small difference from the quote with a dollar deductible.

The Texas Department of Insurance's deductible explanation uses the amount the home is insured for when illustrating a percentage deductible. That is a very different starting point from the cost of a particular repair.

We have not chosen a policy yet. The cheaper premium would help our regular budget, but I want us to understand the amount we might need to find after damage. My partner thinks I am rejecting a saving before we even ask the agent to explain it.

What should we have the agent put into dollars and compare before we decide whether the lower premium is worth the deductible?

Discussion

5 community replies

Put the actual premium saving beside the deductible amount you would have to meet, and discuss where that money would come from. One partner may be focused on keeping the monthly budget manageable and the other on a future bill. Both concerns belong in the comparison; neither is answered by calling a percentage low.

Check more than the deductible line. TDI's roof-insurance guidance explains that roof settlement can involve replacement-cost or actual-cash-value terms, and that wind-and-hail deductibles can differ from other deductibles. Ask the agent to explain the coverage and endorsements on each actual quote so you know what you are comparing.

If the lower-premium policy meets the lender's requirements, would that be a reasonable reason to stop comparing and take it?

I would treat the lender's requirements as one question, then return to the household decision. Ask whether you understand the cover offered and could meet its deductible without relying on money already committed elsewhere. Satisfying a lender would not settle which balance of ongoing premium and possible out-of-pocket cost you can live with.

Join the discussion

More in Housing