Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Money · Advice & Questions ·

Our shared phone bill includes my sister's new handset. Should we still split it evenly?

Money category photographMoney

My sister and I share a mobile plan. Service costs $40 a month in this example, and we've always paid $20 each. We both bought our existing phones separately.

She has now added a new handset with $30 monthly payments. The bill is $70, with no other charges in this example, and she suggested $35 each to keep things simple.

I would be paying $15 more for a phone I won't use. She says sharing the plan gives us both a saving compared with the individual options she checked. We haven't compared those options together or agreed to share device costs.

How would you separate the useful shared service from her phone purchase without turning a small monthly bill into a recurring disagreement?

Discussion

5 community replies

Use the bill's actual lines: $40 for service and $30 for one handset. If you keep the old service split and each funds their own device, the illustrated amounts are $20 for you and $50 for her.

The plan's convenience can be valuable to both of you without making every optional addition a shared expense. Ask what she believes the extra $15 from you would pay for.

Agree how future upgrades, add-ons and any changes in service discounts will be approved and allocated. One message now may prevent a new discussion every billing cycle.

If the new device also changed a plan discount, separating the old $40 service amount might miss part of the real cost.

Then compare the full before-and-after bill and the actual discount conditions. The example has only the two stated charges, but a real agreement should use the real breakdown rather than preserve $20 each by habit or split every total automatically.

Join the discussion

Useful guidance

Compare what each person can afford after essential commitments, then agree which costs are shared. An equal payment and an equally manageable payment can be different things. Choose an arrangement together and give it a review date.

How to discuss splitting bills when your incomes differ →

More in Money