Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Weddings · Advice & Questions ·

Our private wedding-video upload has a music claim. What should we ask the videographer before changing it?

Weddings category photographWeddings

Our videographer delivered a twelve-minute wedding film with the song we requested under the opening section. We uploaded it to YouTube as a private video for relatives. The upload now shows a Content ID music claim and says it is blocked in some places.

My partner thinks the private setting should make the claim a mistake because we are not earning money from the film. I found YouTube’s privacy guidance, which says private videos may still be reviewed for copyright. Its explanation of claims and removal requests distinguishes Content ID claims from removals that result in a copyright strike, and explains that a claim can affect where a video is viewable.

Our contract says we receive a film for personal use, but we have not asked what music permissions were arranged or whether they cover our upload. The videographer has offered to discuss a different soundtrack. We love hearing that song with the pictures, so we do not want to choose in a panic or accuse anyone before understanding what was supplied.

What information should we get first, and how would you weigh keeping the chosen version against commissioning a version we can share as intended?

Discussion

5 community replies

Read the actual claim details before making a decision: which section is identified, what restriction is listed and where it applies. YouTube’s claim guidance explains that blocking can vary by country or region and distinguishes a claim from a removal request. That helps you understand what happened to this upload.

Ask the videographer what permissions were obtained for that recording and composition, what uses those permissions cover, and whether uploading on your own account was included. “Personal use” in your delivery description does not answer those questions by itself. A written explanation would help you understand the options without starting with an accusation.

I would ask for a proposed alternative soundtrack and the cost and scope of that edit before deciding the original song is irreplaceable. Also ask how the new version would preserve the speech and other sound you care about. You might prefer an authorised sharing version once you have something concrete to compare.

Hearing a sample would make that comparison much easier. The emotional attachment may be to the timing of an entrance or a line from a speech as much as the particular song. Ask what can be retained in an edit, and what permissions would cover the replacement version you plan to upload.

Join the discussion

More in Weddings