Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Money · Advice & Questions ·

Our investment mix changed from 60/40 to 75/25 without new purchases. Should we just leave the winners alone?

Money category photographMoney

'Why sell something that's doing well?' my partner asked when I opened our review notes. In this simplified example, the investment mix we chose was 60% stocks and 40% bonds. Changes in value have made it 75% stocks and 25% bonds, without us deliberately choosing a new mix.

We haven't placed any trades. The percentages illustrate drift, not a recommended allocation or current market performance. Our goal and timeframe haven't changed, but we need to check whether the original plan still fits.

Investor.gov describes rebalancing as bringing a portfolio back towards its intended allocation, with costs and tax consequences to consider.

How would you review the decision without treating recent performance as either a command to sell or a reason to accept a different level of risk?

Discussion

5 community replies

Check the current mix across the accounts that belong to this goal. First establish what you actually hold and why the percentages changed; a single account screen may not show the whole plan.

Look for the review rule you agreed, if any: a date, a degree of drift or a change in circumstances. Decide whether that process remains suitable rather than letting the strongest recent performer choose the policy.

Could accepting 75/25 be a reasonable choice if both people now prefer it?

It could be a deliberate decision after reviewing the goal and risks. That is different from adopting it because it emerged on the statement or has recently performed well. Establish why the new mix fits before treating drift as a revised plan.

Join the discussion

More in Money