Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Gaming · Advice & Questions ·

Our group keeps starting new campaigns before the current one gets going

Gaming category photographGaming

Our game group loves a new campaign pitch. We make characters, discuss builds and play two or three sessions. Then someone shares another idea, everyone gets excited, and the current campaign quietly disappears. I've enthusiastically said yes each time too.

I enjoy the early sessions, but I also want to see choices develop into consequences. Our latest game finally has a shared goal, and the chat is already discussing fresh characters for something else. One friend says trying lots of beginnings is the part they enjoy most, which I hadn't understood before.

How do we find out whether we want a continuing campaign or a series of short trials? I don't want to demand that everyone finish a game they're tired of, but saying yes to every new start isn't giving me the kind of play I hoped for.

Discussion

5 community replies

Ask the preference question before debating the next pitch. Your friend has named a real source of enjoyment; if others share it, the group may be doing exactly what they want while you've been expecting something else.

You can say, 'I've been agreeing because the ideas sound fun, but I'd like us to keep one campaign going long enough for our decisions to matter.' Own the earlier yeses without treating them as a permanent commitment to the pattern.

For a future game, agree whether the opening sessions are a trial and when you'll decide to continue. That gives a new pitch somewhere to wait instead of automatically replacing the current game.

Could the group choose a deliberately short arc with an ending you expect to reach? It might offer consequences and closure while leaving room for the people who enjoy fresh starts.

That seems promising if everyone actually wants the arc. Keep space to discuss whether it's working; a shorter commitment helps clarify expectations, but it shouldn't become a demand to keep playing through an unaddressed problem.

Join the discussion

More in Gaming