Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Gaming · Advice & Questions ·

Our GM is offering character bonuses for long backstories. Can I ask for a shorter option?

Gaming category photographGaming

The GM asked for character histories before our next campaign. I sent a page about a failed apprenticeship and the person my character still owes an apology. Then the group chat filled with much longer stories, and the GM announced extra starting benefits for the 'really detailed' submissions.

I like writing a character, but I hadn't understood this as a competition for advantages. I could spend another evening expanding mine; I'd rather discover some of the character through play. The GM says the bonuses are a thank-you for giving them material to use, which I do understand.

Would it be reasonable to ask for another way to provide useful hooks, such as answering a few specific questions? I don't want to dismiss the work the others enjoyed doing, but I also don't want page count to become an extra character-building requirement.

Discussion

5 community replies

Ask what information the GM actually needs to use a backstory. An unresolved obligation and a person who might return could be more usable than several pages without a clear connection to the campaign.

The awkward part is announcing starting benefits after people have already submitted different amounts. You can raise that timing without arguing that longer stories are bad.

A thank-you doesn't have to change a character's starting advantages. The GM could acknowledge the writing or discuss how its details may appear in the story, provided that doesn't simply create another unequal reward.

Would you be comfortable with optional longer submissions if everyone had the same short set of questions to answer for any starting benefit? That separates useful preparation from writing volume.

That would address the concern more closely than a rule limiting everyone's pages. People who enjoy writing can still do it, while the benefit has a clear requirement everyone knew in advance.

Join the discussion

More in Gaming