Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Gaming · Advice & Questions ·

Our GM asked for a roll, then said the action was impossible. What should we clarify?

Gaming category photographGaming

My character tried to climb a cliff before the storm reached us. The GM asked for a roll, called the result good, then said the weather made that route impossible anyway. I asked what the roll had changed and got 'you'll see.' We moved on, but I kept wondering whether I'd misunderstood the choice.

I don't need to know every hidden consequence or have a good roll solve everything. I would like to know whether we're rolling to attempt the climb, avoid an injury, save time or discover that we need another route. How do I ask for clearer stakes without demanding that the GM reveal the whole scene before we play it?

Discussion

5 community replies

Start with the cliff example: 'I thought the roll was about reaching the top. What was it deciding?' That leaves room for an explanation instead of assuming the GM ignored the result.

Hidden consequences can be part of the game. The distinction worth discussing is how much your character understands about the immediate risk before committing to the attempt.

Check how your game's rules describe that roll as well as the table's habits. The group may be attaching different meanings to the same instruction to roll.

It might help to state your intended outcome before the dice: 'I'm trying to reach the top before the storm; is that possible this way?' The GM can then clarify the attempt without revealing every later consequence.

And if the answer is that the roll concerns something else, you can decide whether to make that attempt. Shared stakes don't require a guaranteed success or a preview of the whole adventure.

Join the discussion

More in Gaming