Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Weddings · Advice & Questions ·

Our friend wants her wedding reading to be a surprise. Can we ask for the text after letting her choose?

Weddings category photographWeddings

We asked a close friend to choose a reading for our wedding ceremony because we love the books she recommends. We said about three minutes and no references to having children. She has now told us she found the perfect piece but wants the whole thing to be a surprise.

My partner is happy with that. I would like to read it first, partly because the ceremony has been planned carefully and partly because I don't enjoy being surprised in front of a room. When I asked for the title, she said, “Trust me—you'll cry,” and I didn't know how to answer without seeming suspicious.

We did give her freedom to choose. It would feel unfair to pretend we had always required approval, and I don't want to replace her choice with something of my own simply because it isn't what I expected.

Is it reasonable to ask to see the exact text now? How do I acknowledge that I am adding a condition while keeping the invitation to read it meaningful?

Discussion

5 community replies

Own the late clarification: “We should have said this when we asked. I would love you to read something you chose, but I need to see the words before the ceremony.” That leaves her choice intact while being honest that you hadn't explained your preference.

Your partner may be looking forward to hearing it for the first time. If you see the text and they don't, could that meet both preferences? Only do that with everyone's agreement, and make clear whether a suggested change would then need a conversation with both of you.

Try not to turn “trust me” into an argument about whether she knows you well. You can trust her intentions and still dislike an unrehearsed public surprise. Explain the experience you want rather than listing alarming things she might have chosen.

Set a date for receiving the actual version she plans to read, including any introduction or personal addition. If she no longer wants the role under that condition, offer to choose a different reader without making her attend a negotiation about her friendship.

Including the introduction matters, especially if the poem itself is familiar but the lead-in is personal. I'd make the request about knowing the complete ceremony, rather than correcting her before she's sent anything. A deadline should leave time to talk, not function as a test she can fail overnight.

Join the discussion

More in Weddings