Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Entertainment · Advice & Questions ·

Our film club wants an all-time top ten, and I keep wanting to change mine

Entertainment category photographEntertainment

Our film club is making a sheet of everyone's ten favourite films. I offered my list, then wanted to replace three titles the next day. The organiser joked that entries were final because we couldn't keep reprinting it.

It is a tiny club project, not an award or a published critical canon. Still, I suddenly feel as though the list will expose everything I've forgotten, overrated or failed to see. My partner said, "You were meant to tell them what you love, not sit an exam."

I like the idea of seeing everyone's choices. I just wish mine could say "these ten, today" without sounding as though I'm refusing to play.

Discussion

5 community replies

"Ten favourites today" sounds like a useful title for the sheet, not a refusal. You could suggest it once, then accept that the organiser needs a version to print. Your private favourites can keep changing after the ink dries.

A list can be a starting point for conversation. Someone asking why you chose a film isn't necessarily asking you to defend its permanent place above every film you haven't seen. You can answer with what you enjoyed about it.

You have already supplied the ten titles. Unless you genuinely want a correction, let this edition exist. The next day's impulse to replace three doesn't mean the first list was dishonest.

What are you afraid a missing title will say about you? If the concern is that another member will call a choice unsophisticated, that is a different problem from the list changing naturally. The club activity itself doesn't require you to pre-empt every possible judgement.

And if someone does make it a taste exam, you can decline that framing then. You don't have to solve a hypothetical argument by producing an impossible list now. There is room to say, "I love that one too; it didn't make this ten."

Join the discussion

More in Entertainment