Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Sports · Advice & Questions ·

Our fantasy football draft time is three in the morning for one friend. Is telling him to send a list enough?

Sports category photographSports

“He can just give someone his list,” the organiser said. Nine of our ten friends can make the proposed draft evening. The tenth moved overseas, and that time is three in the morning where he now lives.

This is a free fantasy league with no prizes. Picking teams together is one of the few things we still do as a whole friendship group. Our overseas friend says he'd like to take part, but he doesn't want everyone else to lose a Saturday afternoon on his account. A different time could work if we chose another date; it wouldn't suit everyone's first preference.

We haven't fixed a format or started the draft. A written list would let him have a squad, but he'd miss the conversation and would need to agree how choices were made when his preferred players had gone. I'm worried we're treating a workable team as the same thing as being included.

What would be a fair way to choose the time and format? I don't want to speak over his offer to compromise, but I don't think “nine people prefer this” should end the discussion before we examine alternatives.

Discussion

5 community replies

Ask everyone for workable windows rather than a single favourite evening. With no draft underway, you still have time to compare actual alternatives. Include the overseas friend's local times so the inconvenience isn't hidden behind one group's clock.

Ask him which parts matter most: choosing players himself, the live conversation, or simply staying in the league. Then offer the real options. He may prefer a list, but it should be a choice made with an understanding of what else is possible.

If you do use a proxy or written list, agree how decisions will work and what happens when the list can't answer a question. Don't make another manager guess at his intentions while also building their own squad.

A rotating inconvenience could be reasonable if this becomes a regular problem. But I'd be wary of declaring that everyone must take turns at three in the morning just to make it feel equal. The best available compromise may still be uneven.

Agreed. Look for a workable time first, then acknowledge whatever inconvenience remains. Fairness doesn't need an identical sacrifice from every person; it does need more than assuming the same friend will quietly miss the shared event each year.

Join the discussion

More in Sports