Politics · Advice & Questions · Oct 17

Our family tribute calls Grandad a voice for everyone. My aunt wants that line removed

Politics

"Put his years on the council underneath. Please don't put that he spoke for all of us," my aunt said when I showed her the photograph display.

I'm making it for a family gathering. Grandad's campaign rosette was in the same box as the photograph, and Mum loved the idea of including it. She suggested the caption "A voice for everyone in our town."

My aunt remembers asking him to raise an issue about the play area when she was a young mother. She says he dismissed it. I wasn't there, and I don't want to turn the display into a verdict on a conversation I can't establish. Mum says every tribute simplifies things and that one unhappy memory shouldn't define him.

I can name the role he held without making a claim about everyone he represented. But Mum feels that removing her sentence means I'm siding with my aunt against him. How can I keep the political part of his life in the display without requiring the whole family to endorse a sweeping description?

Discussion

3 community replies

@northstar88

The photograph and rosette already show that public service mattered in his life. You can identify his council role without adding "everyone." Removing that universal claim doesn't require a finding that your aunt's account defines his whole career. It leaves room for family members to remember different aspects.

@softfocus

Mum may be hearing the proposed change as a withdrawal of affection. Ask what she wanted that line to express. Perhaps there is a particular action she remembers proudly and can describe as her memory. A concrete recollection in her voice would be more honest than making the whole town supply agreement.

@JulesAfterDark

Your aunt's recollection shouldn't quietly become a quotation on the display either. She objected to the caption; that isn't permission to make her experience part of the exhibit. Ask before using it, and accept that she may want the broad claim removed without wanting her own conversation displayed.

Our family tribute calls Grandad a voice for everyone. My aunt wants that line removed

Discussion

Join the discussion

More in Politics

Would thanking the losing candidate look like changing sides?

In a practice town-budget exercise, is an equal split always the fairest compromise?

Our policy meeting is upstairs, and the organiser says someone can help with the steps

A federal spending entry shows an obligation. Does that mean the money was paid?