Our cricket ball went over the railway fence. Should I replace it because I refused to fetch it?
SportsA ball I hit during club practice went beyond the boundary fence onto railway land. Someone said there was plenty of time to climb over before the next train. I refused. Nobody went over, and the session has finished.
We're in England. Network Rail's safety campaign warns against entering the railway to retrieve lost sports equipment. I'm not looking for a way to decide when the tracks are safe or a tool to reach the ball from the fence.
Now the captain says I should buy the replacement because the ball would still be available if I had fetched it. I can discuss how the club handles accidentally lost equipment. I don't want that discussion framed as a penalty for refusing a dangerous retrieval.
How would you separate those questions and ask for a sensible plan for future sessions? I don't know whether the club has an agreed replacement policy or has discussed the boundary with the venue.