Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Gaming · Advice & Questions ·

Our casual card nights keep ending with the same tournament deck winning. How do we agree on deck strength?

Gaming category photographGaming

My friend's deck won again before my themed deck reached the combination I'd built it around. He said, "You can use stronger cards too."

All our decks follow the game's rules. We own the cards we are using; nobody has asked anyone to buy more. The difference is what we built for. He enjoys refining a competitive list, while two of us brought decks built around favorite characters and odd interactions.

We called the evening casual, but never explained what that meant. I don't want him to pretend to lose or be ashamed of a good deck. I also don't want every invitation to require building the strongest list I can assemble.

What agreement would make the next evening clearer? We could describe the kind of decks we plan to bring, keep different matchups, or choose another format. I'd like the conversation to happen before another quick loss turns it into a complaint about one person winning.

Discussion

5 community replies

Describe the mismatch in intended play before discussing individual cards. A legal tournament deck and a themed experiment can both belong to somebody's idea of casual. The label hasn't given your group enough information.

Ask your friend what he enjoys about the competitive list. If testing that deck is the point for him, making him quietly weaken it may not produce the shared evening you want. Look for an arrangement he can choose honestly.

Say what a satisfying game would let your deck do, without demanding a guaranteed chance to win. That can help the group distinguish a close contest from an evening where most players never get to try the interactions they brought.

Consider separate invitations for competitive lists and more experimental decks, if enough people want each. People can bring an appropriate deck or decline that format without discovering the expectation after sitting down.

Keep the experimental invitation specific too. It shouldn't become a new argument whenever an unusual deck happens to perform well. Agree on the intended constraints beforehand and leave room for someone to build cleverly within them.

Join the discussion

More in Gaming