Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Gaming · Advice & Questions ·

Our board game's bids are meant to be simultaneous, but someone always reveals last. What should we change?

Gaming category photographGaming

We counted to three, and three players showed their bids. The fourth kept his token behind the screen for another few seconds. He said he was checking the number.

In this game, the choice is supposed to be simultaneous. We pick a bid using in-game resources, then reveal it. Our loose count is making that part of the turn uncomfortable. One friend says the late player is changing his choice after seeing ours. I haven't established that, and I don't want the next round to become an argument about his intentions.

We haven't checked the rulebook's exact procedure since the first session. There may be a clearer way to commit the choices before any values become visible.

What would you change at a casual table? I want everyone working from the same information, with a process that doesn't depend on either trusting a disputed explanation or proving that somebody meant to cheat.

Discussion

5 community replies

Read the actual commitment and reveal procedure together before the next round. Start with what the game already provides. A remembered rule that bids are simultaneous may leave out the step that makes simultaneous choices workable.

If the rules leave room for a table method, agree how every choice is fixed before any value is shown. A face-down commitment might suit the components, or it might reveal other information; check before adopting it.

Describe what you observed: the token remained hidden after others revealed. Don't turn that into a claim that you saw the bid change if you didn't. You can ask for a clearer process without deciding the player's intent.

Walk everyone through one example outside a contested round, including what happens if someone isn't ready. A shared procedure is easier to use when the first attempt isn't also a dispute about who won the bid.

Apply it to every seat, rather than making one person perform an extra demonstration of honesty. If the late reveal continues, address that specific failure to follow the agreed method. You still don't need to invent evidence about what happened behind the screen.

Join the discussion

More in Gaming